Cricut Foiling Tool: Is This Kit Worth It? A Truthful Guide
Let’s talk about the truth behind the Cricut foiling tool.
Not the shiny marketing version.
The real version.
Because foiling with Cricut looks absolutely beautiful online. Metallic lettering. Elegant foil accents. Gorgeous gift boxes.
But does the Cricut foil transfer tool actually perform that way in real life?
Let’s break it down.
Don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter below for the latest tutorials, Cricut gossip, freebies, and password to my SVG Community vault.
What the Cricut Foiling Tool Actually Does
The first thing you need to understand about the Cricut foil transfer tool is this:
It creates an outline.
It does not fill in your design.
If you’re expecting bold, filled metallic lettering… that’s not what the Cricut foil transfer process does. It presses a foil sheet onto your base material following single-line paths inside Design Space.
That means you get foil details, not solid foil coverage.
When you switch your operation in Design Space to “Foil,” you’ll see exactly what I mean. Your design elements convert into traced lines rather than filled shapes.
And that expectation gap is where most beginner frustration begins.
What Comes in the Cricut Foil Transfer Kit
This blog contains affliate links at no extra charge to you, read my full disclosure here.
The Cricut foil transfer kit typically includes:
- The Cricut foil transfer tool housing
- Fine tip
- Medium tip
- Bold tip
- Tape strips
- A few Cricut foil transfer sheets
You can buy additional small foil transfer sheets or 12 x 12 sheets as well. Right now the large sheets are $34+ – LOOK FOR SALES PLEASE!!!
The housing goes into Clamp B on your Cricut Maker or Cricut Explore machine, just like a blade (without the spinning gear at the top).
You can use this system on:
- Cricut Maker
- Cricut Explore machine series
- Cricut Joy (with a specific Joy-sized “blade” and the smaller foil sheet sizes)
So yes, almost any Cricut machine can technically run this new tool.
Compatibility isn’t the issue.
Consistency is.
Setting Up Foiling With Cricut in Design Space
Inside Design Space, you’ll change your operation from “Basic Cut” to “Foil.” You’ll then choose between:
- Fine tip
- Medium tip
- Bold tip
As well as you can pick the colors you want to use, this is important if you are switching between multiple colored foils.
If you’re layering foil accents onto something like cardstock hearts or gift boxes, you must attach your foil layer and your cut layer before hitting “Make.”
Otherwise, your Cricut machine will separate the steps, and your alignment will be off.
In theory, the setup sounds simple.
In reality? Sometimes Design Space has other plans.
I’ve personally experienced it (during this tutorial): it tells me to insert the medium tip and then run the fine tip path first. That mismatch between what the screen says and what the Cricut Maker is doing is frustrating, especially for beginners.
When I buy a tool, I want to follow instructions and get the best results… not troubleshoot mid-project.
The Foil Sheet Setup (This Is Where It Gets Tricky)
Now let’s talk about the foil sheet process.
You place your base material on your mat. Then you place the Cricut foil transfer sheets shiny side up over your design. Then you tape all four edges down.
Here’s the problem:
If that foil sheet shifts even slightly, your foil transfer will be inconsistent.
You’ll get:
- Missing sections
- Blotchy foil effects
- Drag marks
- Uneven foil details
I found that pulling the foil sheet taut and over-taping it helps.
But here’s my honest take: if I’m buying a new tool, I don’t want to be overly worried about perfection here.
Foiling with Cricut often feels like it requires “extra tricks.”
Fine Tip vs Medium Tip vs Bold Tip Results
The Cricut foil transfer tool includes three interchangeable tips:
Fine Tip
Best for delicate design elements and small text.
But in my experience, the fine tip often looks incomplete.
Medium Tip
This is the recommended starting option in Design Space.
It creates slightly thicker foil accents than the fine tip, but still shows inconsistencies up close.
Bold Tip
The bold tip produces the strongest foil effects.
If you’re foiling gift boxes or simple outlines, this tip gives the most visible result.
However, even the bold tip can appear patchy under close inspection.
From far away? It looks pretty.
Up close? You’ll see where foil didn’t fully transfer.
Pressure Settings and Base Material
In Design Space, you’ll select your base material.
Default pressure is what Cricut recommends.
Lower pressure sometimes works a little better, but it’s not standard.
Higher pressure can over-press and cause rough foil details.
But again, the Cricut foil transfer process shouldn’t require endless trial and error.
Comparing It to Foil Quill & Heat Foiling
Now let’s compare.
The foil quill and newer heat-based systems (including Silhouette’s heated foiling pen) actually apply heat to transfer foil.
That means:
- You can fill designs.
- You get bolder foil coverage.
- Foil details appear more solid.
The Cricut foil transfer kit uses pressure only, no heat.
That’s why the foil effects feel lighter and sometimes inconsistent.
If you’re looking for dramatic metallic finishes, heat systems often outperform the Cricut foil method.
When It Actually Works Well
To be fair, the Cricut foiling tool isn’t useless.
It works best for:
- Subtle foil accents
- Minimalist design elements
- Simple gift boxes
- Invitations
- Outline monograms
If you grab the Cricut foil transfer kit on sale, it can be a fun addition to your Cricut machine toolkit.
But at full price? I personally wouldn’t rush to buy it.
My Honest Verdict
Is the Cricut foiling tool worth it?
Only if you can get it on sale.
The Cricut foil transfer system isn’t horrible, but it’s not revolutionary either.
If you:
- Want bold metallic fills
- Expect perfect foil coverage
- Don’t want to troubleshoot Design Space
- Don’t want to tape and tension foil sheets carefully
You may feel frustrated.
If you:
- Like subtle foil details
- Enjoy experimenting
- Can grab the Cricut foil transfer kit at a discount
- Want light foil accents on gift boxes
Then it might be worth adding to your craft room.
Personally? I use it occasionally for embossing hacks (find that here), but I don’t reach for it often when I want strong foil effects.
Final Thoughts on Cricut Foiling Tool
The Cricut foiling tool looks beautiful in marketing photos.
In real crafting? It’s decent, not amazing.
I believe tools should work well straight out of the box. And while the Cricut foil transfer tool can produce pretty results, it often feels more finicky than it should.
If you already bought it and you’re struggling, it’s not just you.
If you’re thinking about buying it, wait for a sale.
And if you’re curious about stronger foil transfer methods, consider comparing heat systems before investing.
As always, stay crafty.
Thank you for this. I got a kit on sale about 6 months ago and haven’t used it yet because I wasn’t sure about it. I was able to pick it and a bunch of transfer sheets on deep discount, which was awesome. I got it to make cards, which I haven’t attempted yet.
You should definitely try it out but be prepared for a bit of a learning curve!
Joy Xtra user. I feel you are a little unfair to the foil process. No, it’s not ever going to look like the promotional photos. McDonald’s burgers never look like their promotional photos either.
–Manage expectation. Like people who expect the marker pen to draw fat, filled in lettering, the foil tip is only a narrow point and can only create narrow lines. The foiling process is more like writing with carbon paper, pushing the foil to contact and stick to the card surface, than applying gilt foil on a surface.
–Manage preparations. The taping down the foil is the essential step. The static in the thin foil film creates a problem. The key to good foiling is wrinkle/pucker-free placement of the foil. Wrinkles are what causes the uneven foiling and can also cause the foil film to rip and shift. I find I can reuse the tape strips many times, like transfer tape. Reusing the foil will cause poor results when the new design traces over places in the foil that have already been used previously. There is no foil in those spots to transfer a second time. The tip to reposition the work area to the bottom of the mat is excellent!
–Conclusion. Foiling is best suited for highlights and accents, not main design/text/object. With my Xtra, I find if I place two foiling lines extremely close together (tiny offset) makes a more pronounced transfer. I don’t use the foil time often (for foiling) but it does what it’s supposed to do. Also, the foil point is excellent for score lines with the Xtra.
I really appreciate you taking the time to write this and I genuinely agree with parts of what you’re saying.
Managing expectations absolutely matters. The foil tip is a narrow point. It will only ever create narrow lines. And yes, prep is everything. Wrinkle-free placement, tight taping, fresh foil, and not overlapping previously used areas all make a difference. Your carbon paper comparison is actually a really great explanation.
That said, I don’t think my opinion is harsh… I think it’s truthful. And sometimes the truth is hard to hear.
My stance isn’t that the tool doesn’t work at all. It just has a ways to go and my concern is whether it performs at a level that matches how it’s marketed, especially for beginners who don’t yet know how to “manage expectations.”
You mentioned McDonald’s burgers not looking like the ads… and that’s fair. But McDonald’s also includes disclaimers about promotional photos versus reality. Is Cricut doing that? Or are new users buying this expecting bold, metallic results because that’s how it’s presented?
I personally don’t think we should expect less from a billion-dollar company. When a product consistently requires tension tricks, heavy taping, tip offset hacks, and troubleshooting to get consistent results, I think it’s fair to say the design could be improved.
Especially when you compare it to heat-based systems. Silhouette’s foiling pen is honestly incredible. It fills designs, produces stronger transfer, and feels more consistent. That shows it can be done differently.
So for me, the conclusion isn’t “this is garbage.” It’s:
It works best for highlights and accents (just like you said) but I think Cricut could absolutely rework and improve the design.
And I truly value your perspective, especially as a Joy Xtra user. I love hearing how different people get it to work well.
That’s what crafting conversations should be: honest experiences on both sides. 💛